
Fourteen guests, six courses and a former taxi dispatch center: Best Fest’s second secret dinner took Halloween underground.
The address arrived by text on Halloween: a warehouse downtown. Nothing on the outside said dinner.
Inside, guests followed a long hallway into a garage, then headed downstairs. Waiting below was the Bat Cave, a former taxi dispatch center washed in orange, red and pink light. A room that once sent cabs out into the city had become a place to settle in for the night.
“It’s magical down here,” one guest said.
All fourteen seats were sold. The location was finally known. The chef and musician were still surprises.
That’s the premise of Best Fest’s second season: ten intimate dinners, one each month, each introducing a chef and a musician who will join the lineup when Best Fest’s 120-foot table returns to Heartwood Preserve in July 2027. Guests receive the address the day of the dinner. The talent stays secret until they arrive.
The evening comes into focus
Tay Westberry, the MasterChef alum hosting Best Fest’s second season, guided the evening. He also hosts Setting The Table, the podcast that gets to know each participating chef, and serves as a connecting presence in the micro-documentaries that introduce them.
FASTER Studios, which produces Best Fest, carries those stories into the dinners themselves. Each evening is filmed with multiple cameras and becomes its own recap film, with guests becoming part of the story as it unfolds.
On Halloween, that story belonged to Chef Sam “Tiny” Laughlin.
His introduction included the debut of a micro-documentary on a 12-by-7-foot LED wall provided by Go Big Screens. No one outside the production had seen the film before that night. For the fourteen people at the table, it was a first look at the person behind the meal they were about to share.
Then Laughlin gave them six courses to get better acquainted, each with its own pairing.
-
·Wild Mushroom Tartlet: Mushroom duxelles, pickled shallot and fresh thyme in crisp butter pastry. Thyme & Honey French 75.
-
·Roasted Beet Salad: Caramelized pumpkin, Granny Smith apple, Gorgonzola dolce espuma and a toasted pepita crumble. Off-dry Riesling.
-
·Seared Diver Scallop: Cauliflower mousseline, caper brown butter, preserved lemon and chive. White Burgundy.
-
·Wild Mushroom Agnolotti: Mushroom duxelles in a Parmesan brodo with crispy sage and parsley oil. Pinot Noir.
-
·Coffee-Crusted Beef Tenderloin: Cultured butter parsnip purée, sherry-glazed baby carrots and a classic beef demi-glace. Right Bank Bordeaux blend.
-
·Espresso Mousse: 70% dark chocolate, tart cherry gel and cocoa nib with Ted and Wally's. Cherry Espresso Martini.
“The food was ridiculous. It was so good,” one guest said.
A first taste
Alongside the espresso mousse came a debut of another kind: the first scoops of Chef Tay’s Best Fest Grand Finale, a brown butter vanilla mocha toffee brownie ice cream created with Ted & Wally’s.
The collaboration gave guests a taste of something that would soon reach beyond the room. After its introduction at the dinner, the flavor went on sale at both Ted & Wally’s locations, available while supplies last.
Marcey Yates, live
The night’s musical reveal was Marcey Yates (“Don’t forget the E”), who performed live while his music videos played across the same LED wall that had introduced Laughlin.
His set brought another part of Omaha’s creative community into the room. Yates also encouraged guests to support Culxr House, an arts and community space that helps artists develop their talents and gives them a place to share their work.
Food, film and live performance each had a place in the evening. So did the conversations happening between them.
The people across the table
For all the planning behind the menu and the reveals, some of the night’s most memorable moments came from the seating arrangements.
One guest, attending with his wife, summed up how quickly the room had become familiar.
“You’re here for the food and the ambiance and all that,” he said. “We got like 10 more best friends.”
Sitting across from his wife had its own advantage.
“I got to look at her all night.”
Go Big Screens founder Zach Gerhart noticed the same change as the evening progressed.
“All these guests came in here as strangers,” he said, “and they became friends just through the power of food and connection.”
By the end of the night, two guests were already looking ahead.
“We’re definitely going to sign up next month.”
Two down, eight to go
Sam Laughlin and Marcey Yates join Danielle Anderson and emcsho in the Best Fest 2027 lineup. Eight more pairings will be revealed the same way, one dinner at a time.
Dinner No. 3 is November 28. The address arrives that day. The rest stays secret.
Best Fest is a FASTER Studios production. Best Fest 2027 is made possible by Go Big Screens, Paladino Development Group, Diehl Event Rentals, Heartwood Preserve, 402 Events, Hosted By Bec and Ted & Wally’s. Omaha Magazine is a media partner of Best Fest.


